Our purpose is to educate the world about the grim situation in North Korea, to decrease apathy, and to ultimately bring change...

Friday, October 13, 2006

No "Extreme Sanctions" on N Korea

Moscow and Beijing are both opposed to "extreme sanctions" on North Korea, Russia's foreign minister says.
"We with China have a common position in the need... not to be emotional," Sergei Lavrov told reporters in Moscow.

The United Nations Security Council is expected to vote on Saturday on a US-sponsored draft resolution calling for sanctions on Pyongyang.

The move follows Monday's announcement by the North that it had tested a nuclear weapon.

The US has revised a draft resolution to remove the threat of imminent military action, in a effort to allay Chinese and Russian concerns.

US ambassador to John Bolton said he expected the vote to be held on Saturday.

"There may some additional changes to the text, but we do have unanimous agreement," he said.

This was confirmed by Japanese envoy Kenzo Oshima, the current council president.


LATEST DRAFT RESOLUTION
Bans sale of tanks, helicopters and missiles, as well as nuclear and missile technology
Allows inspection of ships going to or from N Korea
Bans sale of luxury goods
Bans travel by those working on weapons and missile programmes
Any further action needs new UN resolution

"All council members are asked to come back tomorrow [Saturday]," he said.
Mr Lavrov - after meeting with a senior Chinese envoy in Moscow - said the two countries believed the response should not "give way to emotions" and avoid "extreme sanctions".

The new US draft resolution restricts sanctions to non-military actions and limits arms sanctions to heavy weapons only, but retains a controversial provision allowing nations to inspect cargo moving in and out of North Korea in pursuit of non-conventional weapons.

The resolution urges Pyongyang to implement a September 2005 agreement in which it pledged to give up its nuclear programme in exchange for aid and security guarantees.

Negotiations to resolve outstanding issues are continuing.

'Countermeasures'

Meanwhile, new Japanese sanctions against North Korea have already come into force.

The measures, first announced on Wednesday, include trade and travel bans, barring North Korean ships from Japan's ports, and freezing imports and visits by North Korean officials.


N KOREA NUCLEAR PROGRAMME
Believed to have 'handful' of nuclear weapons
But not thought to have any small enough to put in a missile
Could try dropping from plane, though world watching closely

Pyongyang has promised "strong countermeasures" against any sanctions.

North Korean vessels deliver crabs, clams or prized matsutake mushrooms to Japan, returning with used bicycles, used cars, motorcycles or old household appliances.

Ships have been loading up in Japanese ports ahead of the Friday midnight (1500 GMT) deadline.

US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice is due to tour China, Japan and South Korea next week in an attempt to galvanise support for a strong stance against Pyongyang.

South Korean President Roh Moo-hyun has held talks in Beijing with his Chinese counterpart, Hu Jintao, on how to respond to North Korea's claimed test.

A top South Korean official said the two men did not discuss the details of the draft resolution but agreed in general principle to support UN action.


"The two leaders agreed to support appropriate and necessary counter-measures by the UN Security Council against North Korea," Song Min-soon, Mr Roh's National Security Adviser, said.

Mr Roh is facing increasing pressure at home to reverse his so-called "sunshine policy" of engagement with the North.

As many as 3,000 protesters gathered outside Seoul city hall to demand the government cut off aid and investment.


HAVE YOUR SAY
If the US, UK and other governments wish to stop other countries having nuclear weapons then they should lead by example
Alastair Mooney, Leicester, UK
But there has been some speculation that the test was unsuccessful, based on the relatively small size of the blast.

The US said on Friday that it has so far not established that the North's test had reached the nuclear threshold.

This does not mean that the explosion was not nuclear - just that the tests the US have run thus far cannot definitely conclude that this was the case, officials told the BBC.

Both South Korean and Chinese scientists said they had detected no evidence of radioactivity in air, soil and rainwater tests.

But Yoo Bong-jin, an official with South Korea's ministry of science and technology, warned that the findings were not proof that a nuclear test had failed.




Story from BBC NEWS:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/2/hi/asia-pacific/6046550.stm

Published: 2006/10/13 17:09:28 GMT

© BBC MMVI

Key Stances on N Korea Sanctions

The UN Security Council is set to consider sanctions against North Korea in the wake of its claimed nuclear test.
The BBC News website looks at what sanctions are already in place, and the stance of some of the key countries involved.



US

Despite easing 50-year-old sanctions against North Korea in 2000, the US has had limited trading relations with Pyongyang amid suspicion over its nuclear plans.

Since 2002, when relations began to seriously deteriorate, the US has been calling for a much tougher stance by the international community against North Korea.

In 2003, it launched the Proliferation Security Initiative (PSI) with the aim of interdicting weapons from North Korea, Iran and other countries of concern.

Participating countries were called on to search aircraft and ships suspected of carrying weapons-related material.

In September 2005, Washington imposed financial sanctions on North Korea, accusing it of involvement in the laundering of drug money and counterfeit currency.

It froze the assets of eight firms it believed to be linked to the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, and acted against a bank in Macau accused of helping launder money and of having links with the North Korean leadership.

Following North Korea's test launching of seven missiles in July 2006, the UN Security Council condemned North Korea and called on all members to stop missiles and missile-related technology being transferred to North Korea.

The US took action against 12 companies and one individual under these sanctions.


Following North Korea's claimed nuclear test, the US pushed for a new UN condemnation of North Korea, including reference to the UN's Chapter Seven, which could eventually allow for military action.



JAPAN

Two days after the nuclear test, Japan announced new unilateral sanctions banning all North Korean imports and prohibiting North Korean ships from entering Japanese ports.

North Korean nationals, with a few exceptions, were also barred entry into Japan.

The import ban will hit vital North Korean money-making exports such as mushrooms and clams, as well as coal. Cars, trucks and buses are Japan's main exports to North Korea.

The sanctions came on top of those already imposed after North Korea's missile tests in July 2006.

Japan was instrumental in pushing through that UN resolution, which called on all member states to prevent imports from or exports to North Korea of materials that could be used in weapons of mass destruction.

Tokyo also suspended food aid to North Korea, introduced limited financial sanctions and banned the main North Korean ferry service between the two countries.

SOUTH KOREA

South Korea has been actively trying to engage the North under its so-called "Sunshine Policy" and has stepped up economic, political and humanitarian contacts.

But the policy has drawn criticism from its main ally, the US, and a growing number of people at home who demand a stronger line towards Pyongyang.

After July's missile tests, South Korea cut off regular humanitarian aid, including rice and fertiliser to the North.

But it has been reluctant to support stronger measures for fear of raising tensions with its neighbour. It also fears political or economic collapse in North Korea since this could lead to millions of refugees crossing its border.

For these and other reasons, South Korea had been reluctant to join the US-led Proliferation Security Initiative.

However, following North Korea's claimed nuclear test, Vice-Foreign Minister Yoo Myeong-hwan said the South planned to join "on a partial and case-by-case basis."

CHINA

China is Pyongyang's largest trading partner and closest ally, and played a key role in the now stalled negotiations over North Korea's nuclear programme.

Beijing has flatly condemned North Korea over its nuclear test, but like South Korea it wants to see a stable neighbour and has resisted tough measures called for by the US.

It voted for the UN resolution in July banning missile-related imports, but only after any mention of Chapter Seven was removed.

China has supported "some punitive actions" against North Korea following its nuclear test and has not ruled out sanctions, but says military action would be "unimaginable".

RUSSIA

Russia had strong ties with North Korea during the Soviet era and sees the country as a potential transit route for energy pipelines.

Like China - another veto-wielding member of the UN Security Council - Russia has been inclined towards coaxing the North rather than punishing it.

Russia has also condemned North Korea's nuclear test but said military action is not the answer and again called for the issue to be resolved through diplomatic means

Moscow has not publicly stated what, if any, sanctions it would agree too.

AUSTRALIA

Australia, along with Japan, followed the US by announcing financial sanctions against North Korea in September 2006.

The sanctions involved freezing the transfer of money to North Korea by 12 groups and one person suspected of having links to its nuclear or missile programmes, Canberra said.

UK

The UK has a similar position to the US.

Following the nuclear test, Foreign Secretary Margaret Beckett said the UK would be pushing strongly for sanctions and for Chapter Seven to be invoked in the UN.

She said any new UN resolution must go further than the sanctions on missile-related imports and exports already in place.


Story from BBC NEWS:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/2/hi/asia-pacific/6043610.stm

Published: 2006/10/12 13:44:14 GMT

© BBC MMVI

Thursday, October 12, 2006

North Korea: Ending Food Aid would Deepen Hunger

Resume Food Aid to North Korea’s Vulnerable Population

(London, October 11, 2006) – Emergency food aid to North Korea should not be suspended in response to the country’s alleged nuclear test, Human Rights Watch said today. Since the mid 1990s, North Korea has been dependent on foreign aid to feed up to one third of its population.

On Monday, Pyongyang’s state-controlled Korea Central News Agency announced that North Korea had successfully conducted an underground nuclear test. South Korea’s Defense Ministry told reporters that they detected an explosion on Monday morning near Kilju, on the northeastern coast of North Korea near China.

“As the international community responds to North Korea’s nuclear test, it must distinguish between the North Korean government and ordinary citizens,” said Sophie Richardson, deputy Asia director at Human Rights Watch. “Further restraints on food aid will only make ordinary North Koreans suffer more.”

After North Korea announced its nuclear test on Monday, South Korea said it would cut off its emergency aid for the flood damage that North Korea suffered this summer as well. When North Korea test fired seven ballistic missiles on July 5, the world was quick in expressing grave concerns. Only 10 days later, the United Nations Security Council adopted a resolution condemning the launch. South Korea protested the missile launch in a high-level inter-Korea meeting in July; when North Korea refused to discuss the issue, Seoul decided to suspend its food aid.

Demographic experts believe that about 1 million North Koreans perished in the 1990s because of food shortage and hunger-related diseases. Human Rights Watch has expressed grave concerns for the North Koreans’ right to food in a recent report, “A Matter of Survival: The North Korean Government’s Control of Food and the Risk of Hunger.” A series of policy changes that North Korea adopted last year could lead to renewed hunger, the report warned.

Although it is difficult to precisely gauge conditions in North Korea, there are serious indications that another food crisis is looming. According to the World Food Programme (WFP), hundreds were killed and tens of thousands of North Koreans were left homeless in recent floods. Last year, North Korea received about 1 million tons of food aid, about half coming from each China and South Korea. North Korea has most likely run out of last year’s harvest by now, and its harvest this year suffered from massive floods. WFP estimates this year suggest that North Korea currently lacks 800,000 metric tons of grain, or approximately one-sixth of the county’s total annual food needs.

“North Korea’s nuclear weapons program can have devastating security implications in the region, but suspending food aid could be lethal for ordinary North Koreans,” said Richardson.

Some North Korea watchers oppose food aid to North Korea, citing suspicion that some of the aid is diverted to the military instead of reaching the needy. But Human Rights Watch’s research has shown that members of the military and ordinary civilians alike suffer from hunger and food shortages.

Seoul should resume food aid to North Korea, and all aid donors should use this occasion to press for proper monitoring of distribution to ensure food reaches the intended beneficiaries, those most vulnerable to malnutrition and starvation. China should not cut its food aid. The United States, Japan and other donors should resume food aid as well. If this aid has been a purely humanitarian gesture, it should not be affected by non-humanitarian reasons. All those concerned with North Koreans’ welfare should prepare to provide assistance to a potential surge in refugees.

“The welfare and possibly even survival of many ordinary North Koreans is in the hands of the international community now,” Richardson said.

Human Rights Watch

Divisions over N Korea sanctions

UN Security Council members have yet to agree on a new draft of a US resolution calling for sanctions on North Korea over its claimed nuclear test.
The US had wanted a vote on the draft by Friday but diplomatic sources told the BBC China and Russia opposed this.

The draft targets the North's missile and nuclear programmes under the UN's Chapter Seven - which makes sanctions mandatory and may allow using force.

China and Russia are reportedly worried about how sanctions may be enforced.


HAVE YOUR SAY
If the US, UK and other governments wish to stop other countries having nuclear weapons then they should lead by example
Alastair Mooney, Leicester, UK

During talks on Thursday, they asked for more time to consider the US proposals.

Western diplomats believe China's support for the draft resolution is essential if tough action is to be taken against North Korea, says the BBC's UN correspondent, Laura Trevelyan.

Japanese sanctions

North Korea's underground test reportedly took place at 1036 (0136 GMT) on Monday in Gilju in north-east Hamgyong province.


US SANCTIONS PROPOSAL
Halting trade in material that could be used to make weapons of mass destruction
Inspections of cargo going in and out of North Korea
The ending of financial transactions used to support nuclear proliferation
A ban on the import of luxury goods

Russia is the only country to have confirmed that it was a nuclear explosion, amid speculation the test was not wholly successful.

South Korea said on Thursday that it had not detected any abnormal radioactivity levels on its soil after its northern neighbour's alleged nuclear test.

On Wednesday, Japan imposed its fresh sanctions on North Korea, including banning all imports from the country. The sanctions are expected to be approved by the Japanese cabinet on Friday.

Pyongyang responded by saying it will take "strong countermeasures" against Japan if the sanctions are enforced.


N KOREA NUCLEAR PROGRAMME
Believed to have 'handful' of nuclear weapons
But not thought to have any small enough to put in a missile
Could try dropping from plane, though world watching closely

There is agreement in the UN Security Council that North Korea should face punitive measures, but countries are divided over how tough these should be.

The US wants the sanctions - which would also target luxury goods - to be brought under Chapter Seven of the UN Charter.

This means they would be mandatory and ultimately enforceable by military means.

The draft resolution also includes a clause allowing nations to ban the entry or transit of people believed to support Pyongyang's weapons programme, reports say.

But China, Russia and South Korea have expressed varying degrees of opposition.

China is also reported to be unhappy about authorising inspections of cargo vessels moving in and out of North Korea in order to find weapons-related material.



Story from BBC NEWS:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/2/hi/asia-pacific/6042920.stm

Published: 2006/10/12 19:18:55 GMT

© BBC MMVI

Monday, October 09, 2006

N Korea "nuclear test" condemned

The UN Security Council has strongly condemned North Korea's claim to have tested a nuclear weapon underground.
The emergency meeting will also debate what further steps should be taken, including binding sanctions.

President George W Bush said the US is working to confirm the test claim. He branded it a "provocative" act threatening peace and stability.

He said he and regional leaders agreed North Korea's actions were unacceptable and deserved an immediate UN response.

Japan's UN ambassador, Kenzo Oshima, urged North Korea to refrain from further testing and to return to six-party talks.

He said the Security Council would now begin work on a resolution being drafted by the United States.

The session comes three days after the council agreed a formal statement urging North Korea to cancel any planned nuclear test and return to disarmament talks.

BBC diplomatic correspondent Jonathan Marcus says a tough resolution condemning North Korea's actions is expected, but more time may be needed to draft a text.


N KOREA NUCLEAR PROGRAMME
Believed to have 'handful' of nuclear weapons
But not thought to have any small enough to put in a missile
Could try dropping from plane, though world watching closely

Our correspondent adds that the key question is how any threat of sanctions will be framed; whether this will be a Chapter Seven resolution - one recognising that North Korea's action represents a threat to peace that would make sanctions mandatory.

Resolutions brought under this chapter the UN Charter are legally binding and can authorise military action.

UK Foreign Secretary Margaret Beckett said the UK would be "pushing for a robust response" under Chapter Seven.

"Put simply, this means we shall be pushing for sanctions against North Korea," she said.

US ambassador to the UN John Bolton said that although responses were preliminary, he was "very impressed by the unanimity of the Council on the need for a strong and swift answer".

"I didn't see any protectors of North Korea in that room," he said.

But North Korea's ambassador, Pak Gil Yon, said the Security Council should congratulate Pyongyang instead of issuing "useless" resolutions.

'Unpardonable'

In his first public statement, the US president said the North Korean claim "constitutes a threat to international peace and security."

He said he had telephoned Chinese, Japanese, Russian and South Korean leaders, who had all reaffirmed their commitment to a nuclear-free Korean peninsula.

"Once again, North Korea has defied the will of the international community, and the international community," he said.


"The nuclear test... marks a historic event... It will contribute to defending the peace and stability on the Korean peninsula and in the area around it
North Korean statement
"The North Korea regime remains one of the world's leading proliferators of missile technology including transfers to Iran and Syria."

Mr Bush added that the development would not help North Korea's "oppressed and impoverished" people, who deserved a better future.

Earlier Japan's Prime Minister Shinzo Abe - visiting Seoul - called the claimed test "unpardonable".

He warned the region was "entering a new, dangerous nuclear age".

South Korean President Roh Moo-hyun feared the move could "spark a nuclear arms build-up in other countries".

In an unusually strong statement against its ally, China said the claimed test "defied the universal opposition of international society".

Meanwhile, the head of the South's intelligence service said it had detected more movement at another North Korean test site and he could not rule out further nuclear tests.

'No radiation leak'

South Korean media said the test took place in Gilju in Hamgyong province at 1036 (0136 GMT).

The size of the bomb is uncertain, with estimates varying from 550 tons of destructive power to as much as 15 kilotons. The 1945 Hiroshima bomb was 12.5-15 kilotons.


KOREAN NUCLEAR CRISIS
Sept 2005: At first hailed as a breakthrough, North Korea agrees to give up nuclear activities
Next day, N Korea says it will not scrap its activities unless it gets a civilian nuclear reactor
US imposes financial sanctions on N Korea businesses
July 2006: N Korea test-fires seven missiles
UN Security Council votes to impose sanctions over the tests
Oct 2006: N Korea claims to have carried out nuclear test

But our correspondent points out the claimed test does not necessarily mean North Korea has a fully-fledged nuclear bomb or warhead that it can deliver to a target.

North Korea's KCNA news agency described the test as an "historic event that brought happiness to our military and people".

It said the test would maintain "peace and stability" in the region and was "a great leap forward in the building of a great prosperous, powerful socialist nation". There was no radiation leak, it said.

Pyongyang pulled out of the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty in 2003 and has refused for a year to attend talks aimed at ending its nuclear ambitions.


Story from BBC NEWS:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/2/hi/asia-pacific/6034873.stm

Published: 2006/10/09 16:55:02 GMT

© BBC MMVI

Saturday, October 07, 2006

Why Pyongyang May Test Its Bomb

Oct. 16, 2006 issue - East Asia could be on the verge of the nightmare it has been trying to avert for so long: a North Korean nuclear test that could set off a destabilizing WMD arms race in that part of the world. Last week Pyongyang announced it intends to test a nuclear bomb soon, and most U.S. and Chinese officials say they believe the statement was not merely a bargaining ploy. "It's as serious as a heart attack," says Frederick Jones of the National Security Council.

As evidence, U.S. officials point to the carefully constructed official statement issued by North Korea's Foreign Ministry—and the fact that its intention to test was broadcast to the North Korean people themselves. "The North Koreans always do what they say they're going to," says Jones.

U.S. officials now believe the only nation that can persuade North Korea to stand down is China, which has taken the lead in the long-suspended Six-Party Talks with Pyongyang (the other participants are the United States, Russia, South Korea and Japan). In the past Beijing has either temporarily interrupted or threatened to cut off North Korea's critical energy supplies, including oil and electricity, according to three U.S. officials familiar with intelligence reporting on Korea, who spoke on condition of anonymity because the details are classified. Washington's hope is that Beijing will do the same now.

Chinese officials, however, suggest that even if they do move to punish Pyongyang, it may not do any good. They note that North Korean leader Kim Jong Il ignored Beijing's pleas when China tried to intervene with him this summer. China had insisted that Kim not test new missiles, but he went ahead anyway and fired off seven across the Sea of Japan in a macabre July 4 celebration. Shen Dingli, a senior Chinese foreign-policy analyst, has concluded it's too late to deter Kim from exploding a nuclear bomb. In a remarkably candid commentary published in a newspaper of the Communist Party's China Youth League last week, Shen warned that Pyongyang has already concluded that its national interests—including its nuclear ambitions—now eclipse the importance of its relations with China. Shen said Kim's regime believes it needs to test a bomb because that will unmistakably demonstrate its nuclear capability, which, in turn, will deter America from attacking it.

If Kim does test, what will Washington do? The lead U.S. negotiator, Assistant Secretary of State Christopher Hill, delivered the starkest warning yet to Pyongyang last week, saying North Korea "can have a future or it can have these weapons. It can't have both." U.S. officials say Hill was not threatening war, but rather referral to the U.N. Security Council under Chapter 7, which could mean new sanctions and increasing isolation. One U.S. intel official who has long followed North Korea (and requested anonym-ity because of the sensitivity of the subject) said that Kim Jong Il is behaving "like a bad-tempered teenage child." Perhaps, but most children don't play with nuclear bombs.

http://msnbc.msn.com/id/15176150/site/newsweek/

Thursday, October 05, 2006

Russians "in N Korea Test Talks"

Russia says it is in direct contact with North Korea to try to prevent it from carrying out its plan to test a nuclear weapon.
Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said Moscow was talking to the North Korean leadership in an attempt to dissuade it from conducting a test.

It comes two days after North Korea said it would test a nuclear weapon.

The announcement drew warnings from the international community to North Korea not to take such a step.

The secretive communist regime says it possesses nuclear weapons, but this has not been independently verified.

Pyongyang has been involved in on-off six-party talks with Russia, the US, China, Japan and South Korea to resolve the crisis over its nuclear programme.

Earlier this week, US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice said a nuclear test by North Korea would be a "very provocative act".

White House spokesman Tony Snow said on Thursday it was "enormously important" that North Korea was not allowed to develop nuclear weapons.

But he said US warnings did not amount to a "lethal threat" against Pyongyang.

Aid deal

Speaking to reporters while on a visit to Warsaw, Poland, Mr Lavrov said Moscow was working directly with the North Korean government to ease the situation.


"We are all very worried about this," the minister was quoted by AFP news agency as saying.

"We are talking about moves we can take and working directly with the leaders of North Korea to try to convince them to hold back from committing any act which could worsen the situation."

Mr Lavrov said that in the interests of the non-proliferation of nuclear weapons and security on the Korean peninsular, it was important that North Korea returned to the six-party negotiations.

The most recent round of talks ended in September 2005, with a deal which promised economic aid in return for Pyongyang scrapping its nuclear ambitions.


HAVE YOUR SAY
It has always been obvious that the nuclear threat is the only card left for North Korea
Shinya Yoshida, Tokyo
That agreement, however, appears to have fallen apart over disagreements on its implementation.
North Korea has not specified where or when a nuclear test might be carried out.

In continuing diplomatic efforts to defuse the crisis, South Korean President Roh Moo-hyun is due to hold talks with US President George W Bush in Washington on Thursday.

His visit comes amid talks of a split between Washington and Seoul on how to handle Pyongyang, after President Roh appeared to downplay North Korea's recent missile tests.

Story from BBC NEWS:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/2/hi/asia-pacific/5410066.stm

Published: 2006/10/05 19:29:04 GMT

© BBC MMVI